James Gregory Marlow and Cynthia Lynn Coffman were a couple whose 1986 crime spree ended with two murder convictions and death sentences in California. Their case involved kidnapping, robbery, sexual assault and murder, and the pair eventually became one of the more notorious criminal couples in California history.
Marlow and Coffman were convicted of the murder of 20-year-old Corinna Novis in San Bernardino County. Marlow was later convicted of the murder of 19-year-old Lynell Murray in Orange County. Both defendants received death sentences for their roles in the Novis case, while Marlow was separately sentenced to death following his conviction in the Murray case.
The case surrounding James Gregory Marlow and Cynthia Coffman remains notable not only because of the brutality of the crimes, but also because the two defendants eventually blamed each other for what happened.
Who Were James Gregory Marlow and Cynthia Coffman?
James Gregory Marlow and Cynthia Lynn Coffman were lovers who traveled together before arriving in California in 1986.
According to contemporary reporting, the pair had a turbulent relationship. Coffman later maintained that Marlow exercised control over her and that she feared what would happen if she attempted to leave him. Prosecutors, however, portrayed Coffman as a willing participant in the crimes.
The two eventually found themselves facing murder charges in San Bernardino County after the disappearance and killing of Corinna Novis.
Their relationship would become an important part of the subsequent trials, with each side presenting a very different explanation of Coffman's role in the killings. Contemporary coverage described the former lovers as having become bitter adversaries by the time their trial began.
The Murder of Corinna Novis
The first murder for which James Marlow and Cynthia Coffman were convicted involved 20-year-old Corinna Novis.
On November 7, 1986, Novis disappeared after leaving the Redlands Mall area in San Bernardino County. She had been driving a white Honda CRX.
According to the prosecution's case, Marlow and Coffman encountered Novis and obtained a ride from her. She was subsequently taken to a residence, where she was restrained and sexually assaulted.
Novis was eventually strangled. Her body was dumped in a field near Fontana.
Contemporary newspaper reports stated that Marlow and Coffman were convicted of Novis' murder in 1989. The California Supreme Court later reviewed the convictions and upheld the judgment.
The case involved far more than the murder itself. The defendants were convicted of murder, kidnapping, kidnapping for robbery, robbery, residential burglary and forcible sodomy. The jury also found special-circumstance allegations involving the circumstances surrounding the murder.
Who Was Corinna Novis?
Corinna Novis was a 20-year-old woman from the Redlands area whose disappearance on November 7, 1986, triggered an investigation that ultimately led authorities to Marlow and Coffman.
Her murder became the central case against the pair in San Bernardino County.
Novis' car, personal belongings and financial records also became important pieces of the investigation. According to contemporary accounts, authorities connected the couple to the crime through evidence discovered after Novis disappeared.
The Murder of Lynell Murray
The crimes did not end with Corinna Novis.
Five days later, 19-year-old Lynell Murray was abducted from the Huntington Beach dry-cleaning business where she worked.
Murray was a college student who worked part-time at the business. According to court records and contemporary reporting, Marlow and Coffman robbed the business and forced Murray into Novis' Honda.
Murray was taken to a Huntington Beach motel, where she was sexually assaulted and murdered.
The circumstances surrounding Murray's death later became the subject of a separate prosecution.
Marlow eventually pleaded guilty to the murder, kidnapping, robbery and rape of Lynell Murray. The California Supreme Court record states that he also pleaded guilty to burglary and admitted special circumstances involving the murder.
Coffman's involvement was also prosecuted, and her defense maintained that she had been under Marlow's control.
Cynthia Coffman's Role
One of the most controversial aspects of the case was the question of exactly how much control James Marlow exercised over Cynthia Coffman.
Coffman testified about the Murray killing during the earlier proceedings and claimed that Marlow directed her actions. Her defense later argued that she had been abused and controlled by him.
Prosecutors presented a different picture.
They argued that Coffman was an active participant rather than simply a victim of Marlow's influence.
The disagreement over Coffman's role became a central issue during the trials and sentencing proceedings. Contemporary reporting shows that Coffman's lawyers attempted to persuade jurors that her relationship with Marlow and the abuse she allegedly suffered should be considered when determining her punishment.
Ultimately, the jury convicted Coffman in the Novis case and recommended the death penalty.
The Capture of Marlow and Coffman
Following the murders, authorities began searching for the couple.
Their movements eventually led investigators to the pair in the Big Bear area.
Contemporary accounts describe a large search effort involving more than 100 people. Marlow and Coffman were eventually captured while hiking in the mountains.
The clothing they were wearing was reportedly connected to the Huntington Beach dry-cleaning business where Murray had worked. Their capture brought an end to the brief but deadly crime spree.
The 1989 Trial and Death Sentences
The murder of Corinna Novis became the first major trial involving Marlow and Coffman.
Both were convicted of murder and several additional offenses.
In 1989, juries recommended that both defendants receive the death penalty. Contemporary reports describe Marlow and Coffman as blaming each other as the case progressed through the courts.
Coffman's defense argued that she had been controlled and abused by Marlow. Marlow's defense, meanwhile, attempted to portray Coffman as having influenced him.
The conflicting accounts made their relationship a major feature of the proceedings.
Formal judgments of death were entered against both defendants in August 1989.
The California Supreme Court Appeal
The convictions and death sentences eventually reached the California Supreme Court.
In People v. Coffman & Marlow, the California Supreme Court reviewed the San Bernardino County convictions and ultimately affirmed the judgment in August 2004.
The court record provides a detailed account of the evidence and legal arguments surrounding the Novis murder.
The court's opinion confirms that both defendants were convicted of murder as well as kidnapping, kidnapping for robbery, robbery, residential burglary and forcible sodomy.
The case is particularly useful for researchers because it provides a primary legal record rather than relying solely on newspaper accounts or later true-crime summaries.
James Gregory Marlow's Second Murder Conviction
Marlow's legal case did not end with the Novis conviction.
He was separately prosecuted in Orange County for the murder of Lynell Murray.
According to the California Supreme Court, Marlow pleaded guilty to Murray's murder, kidnapping, robbery, rape and burglary. He also admitted that the murder occurred during the commission of robbery, burglary and rape and that he was armed with a firearm during the offenses.
The Murray case therefore established a second murder conviction against Marlow.
Coffman was also prosecuted for her involvement in the Murray killing, with her defense again emphasizing her relationship with Marlow and allegations that he had controlled her.
Were James Gregory Marlow and Cynthia Coffman Serial Killers?
Marlow and Coffman are frequently described in true-crime literature as serial killers or a serial-killer couple because they were responsible for multiple killings occurring during the same 1986 crime spree.
However, it is important to distinguish between popular descriptions and the precise legal record.
Marlow was convicted of the murders of both Corinna Novis and Lynell Murray. Coffman was convicted of Novis' murder and prosecuted for her role in the Murray case.
The California Supreme Court's records are the strongest source for establishing the actual convictions and offenses.
What Happened to James Gregory Marlow and Cynthia Coffman?
Both Marlow and Coffman received death sentences in connection with the Novis murder.
Their convictions and sentences were subsequently subjected to lengthy appeals and other legal proceedings.
The California Supreme Court affirmed the judgment in the Coffman and Marlow case in 2004. The United States Supreme Court later denied petitions for certiorari from both defendants.
The case therefore continued through the courts for decades after the original 1986 murders.
Why the Marlow and Coffman Case Remains Notorious
The case of James Gregory Marlow and Cynthia Coffman stands out for several reasons.
First, the crimes occurred within a very short period. Corinna Novis disappeared on November 7, 1986, and Lynell Murray was abducted and murdered only days later.
Second, the victims were strangers to the couple. The attacks were opportunistic, with the defendants using robbery, kidnapping and sexual violence as part of the crimes.
Third, the relationship between Marlow and Coffman became an important question during the trials. Coffman claimed that Marlow's influence and alleged abuse affected her actions, while prosecutors argued that she was a willing participant.
Finally, the case generated decades of appeals, leaving behind an unusually detailed collection of court records.
James Gregory Marlow and Cynthia Coffman: A Timeline
November 7, 1986: Corinna Novis disappears in the Redlands area.
November 7, 1986: Novis is kidnapped, assaulted and murdered.
November 12, 1986: Lynell Murray is abducted from the Huntington Beach dry-cleaning business where she worked.
November 12, 1986: Murray is murdered at a Huntington Beach motel.
November 1986: Authorities capture Marlow and Coffman following a search.
1989: Marlow and Coffman are convicted in the Novis murder case.
August 1989: Both receive death sentences for their roles in Novis' murder.
1992: Marlow pleads guilty to the murder of Lynell Murray and related offenses.
2004: The California Supreme Court affirms the judgment in the Coffman and Marlow case.
2005: The U.S. Supreme Court denies their petitions for certiorari.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who were James Gregory Marlow and Cynthia Coffman?
James Gregory Marlow and Cynthia Lynn Coffman were a couple convicted in connection with murders committed in California in 1986. They were convicted of murdering Corinna Novis, while Marlow was separately convicted of murdering Lynell Murray.
Who did James Gregory Marlow and Cynthia Coffman kill?
Marlow and Coffman were convicted in connection with the murder of 20-year-old Corinna Novis. Marlow was separately convicted of murdering 19-year-old Lynell Murray.
Who was Corinna Novis?
Corinna Novis was a 20-year-old woman who disappeared in the Redlands area on November 7, 1986. Marlow and Coffman were subsequently convicted of her murder.
Who was Lynell Murray?
Lynell Murray was a 19-year-old Huntington Beach woman who was abducted from the dry-cleaning business where she worked on November 12, 1986. James Marlow was later convicted of her murder.
Were James Marlow and Cynthia Coffman married?
Contemporary reporting described Marlow and Coffman as lovers who married during their travels in 1986. Their relationship later became a major issue during their criminal trials.
Did James Gregory Marlow receive the death penalty?
Yes. Marlow received a death sentence in connection with the murder of Corinna Novis and was also sentenced to death following his conviction in the Lynell Murray case. The California Supreme Court later reviewed his convictions and appeals.
Did Cynthia Coffman receive the death penalty?
Yes. Coffman was sentenced to death for her conviction in the murder of Corinna Novis. Her case went through the California appellate system for many years.
Final Thoughts
The story of James Gregory Marlow and Cynthia Coffman is one of the darker criminal cases to emerge from California in the 1980s.
What began as the relationship between two people traveling across the country ultimately ended with multiple murders, kidnapping, robbery, sexual violence and two death sentences.
The case also illustrates why the label of a "serial killer couple" can sometimes obscure the complicated legal history behind a crime. While Marlow and Coffman are frequently grouped together, their individual convictions, alleged roles and subsequent legal proceedings were not identical.
The surviving court records provide the clearest picture of what was proven in court: James Gregory Marlow and Cynthia Lynn Coffman were convicted in the murder of Corinna Novis, while Marlow was separately convicted of the murder of Lynell Murray. Their appeals continued for decades, making the case one of the more extensively documented murder cases from California's 1980s crime history.










